Skip to main content

The Obsession With Ratings. Warranted Or Not?


(Just a bit of a heads-up, this article contains a lot of the word "ratings"). 

Rating. Rating. Rating. It is a word that you see or hear many times throughout your wrestling fandom but why is that? 

Well, it's interesting to see how your weekly consumption does by the numbers every week. 

However, that conversation can turn the other way. 

The toxic, "logic-filled", gatekeeping way that is (you see why I muted the word "rating" on Twitter?). 


AEW Dynamite secures victory in inaugural week against WWE's NXT ...


Fans have been talking about TV ratings for years but that discussion has skyrocketed once AEW Dynamite and NXT airs on the same night every week ya know because wrestling fans am I right? 

Before I answer the question of whether the obsession with TV ratings is warranted or not, I'll first have to briefly describe the Nielsen rating (which is an American TV rating system. No sh*t, Omar). 

A Summary Of The History Of The Nielsen Ratings. 

Arthur Nielsen

The Nielsen rating system was introduced by Nielsen Media Research founded by a marketing analyst named Arthur C. Niesen in the 1920s. 

It was first implemented and measured for the radio to determine the average audience, cumulative audience and total audience. The scale was then later used for television in the 1950s. 

Keep this in mind, this system isn't flawless.  To my understanding (because I'm not an expert), Nielsen calculates a small sample of people out of the whole population in an area. 

In Nielsen's website, they compared that small sampling to a scientist getting a sample of water from a lake. 

brown wooden dock near calm body of water surrounded by trees


Which, that isn't the most accurate thing in my opinion, as they are different demographics that watch certain programs. 

I think reaching a wider number instead of a small sample will help the accuracy but that's just me. 

Now, you're probably asking, "well, what's the alternative of the Nielsen study?"

Let's read from what Alan Wurtzel (who was a president of research and media development for NBCUniversal and now a senior advisor for NBC) had to say about that in a 2011 Vulture article

"Listen, Nielsen is a monopoly. They’re the only game in town. [Their ratings] are the only currency.”

With that out of the way, let's answer the main question. 

woman in gray top
Please God, let the conversation about this topic be civil. 


Is the obsession with ratings warranted or better yet, do ratings even matter? 

The answer is yes and no. Ratings do matter to different people in the industry with different sets of skills and expectations *cough, cough TV executives and advertisers*. 

Ratings, however, do not matter to average viewers like us because it really doesn't dictate our overall thoughts on certain episodes. 

That is not to say that you can't be curious about how the entity you consume does in the Nielsen rating. 

Just because a TV show did low numbers, that doesn't mean that it's a horrendous piece of programming and vice versa.


That's how I feel about the topic. Let me know if ratings do matter from an audience perspective or not in the comments below.

Follow me on Twitter @omartheplayaguy and as always, stay safe smarks. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The 5 News Week: An Interview With ROH's Eli Isom, Fans Singing Petitions For Charlotte Flair Not Winning Titles Anymore!?

Hello, my fellow wrestling fans and welcome to the 5 news week. The post where I report 5 major or minor news of the week that I don't have time to do it separately. Without further ado, here are the 5 news week. An Interview With ROH's Eli Isom.  Yes. After several and several and several of The 5 News Week articles that I've been putting out since late 2018, I finally got an interview for you guys.  The person in question is Ring Of Honour's Eli Isom. Since graduating from the ROH Dojo, Isom has worked and learned from the absolute best in the industry:  "I’m lucky that I got a chance to train from scratch with ROH, without that kind of training who knows where I’d be right now." So, without further ado, here is the conversation I had with Eli.  Omar: My first question is, how would you describe the persona of "Eli Isom" to resident WWE shills like myself? Eli Isom: For me, my wrestling persona isn’t too far off from who I real...

The 5 News Week: Master P Buying House Of Glory!?, NXT TV To Air In Different Arenas!?

Hello, my fellow wrestling fans and welcome to the 5 news week. The post where I report 5 major or minor news of the week that I don't have time to do it separately. Without further ado, here are the 5 news week . Sorry for not posting in two days. Just some personal stuff I gotta deal with and my Coherent Wednesdays review was a bit rushed and I want to nail it in a no pun intended, coherent matter if that makes any sense? Hopefully, my reviews will get better in the coming weeks.  Master P Buying House Of Glory!?  A great example of human beings having an unpredictable nature to them (ask Vince McMahon), Master P was interviewed somewhere in Manhattan and he announced that he has brought an independent wrestling promotion based in New York called House Of Glory or HOG which was founded by Brian XL and Impact Alumni Amazing Red in 2014.  PWInsider and Mike Johnson gave an update to this story stating that Master P will deliver the "muscle and production team" goi...

WWE NXT 17/7/19 | My Coherent Review.

I didn't feel anything about this show overall besides one very good match and an impactful debut. Here's why.  Matt Riddle vs Arturo Ruas.  Those two guys have a background in MMA so it was really interesting as to how the match turned out. Started out with some technical wrestling which if you've been a follower of this blog then you'll know how much I LOVE technical submission wrestling.   The match ended with Matt Riddle delivering a series of rights and the ref stopped it which means that Matt won the match. After that, a masked man revealed as Killan Dan was beating the crap out of him and it was so bad that Mauro Ranallo screamed "Mamma Mia" on top of his lungs which is pretty rare. I actually really liked this. It's a different way to debut somebody and insert that person quickly in a feud instead of having that superstar wrestle in so many squash matches which I don't mind if they went in that route.  The Street Profits ...